CP Rail sued by ADM for service disruptions, allegedly resulting from ‘imprudent cost-cutting’

CHICAGO — Archer Daniels Midland Co has filed a lawsuit against Canadian Pacific over service disruptions in 2013 and 2014 at crop-processing plants in North Dakota and Minnesota, alleging they stemmed in part from cost-cutting and the Canadian railroad’s pursuit of merger partners.

Chicago-based ADM, among the world’s largest grain traders and processors, filed suit against CP within the U.S. District Court for that Central District of Illinois on March 18, seeking damages “resulting from among the worst and most persistent railroad service failures felt by ADM in lots of years.”

The U.S. rail system has long served because the lone, dependable way to move grain a large number of miles in the northern U.S. Plains, where you can find no commercially navigable rivers.

In early 2014, farmers within the Upper Midwest held the largest grain stocks in years after months of worsening delays that crippled the U.S. farm transportation system.

Related

Canadian Pacific Railway gives in, seeks ruling on Norfolk Southern deal from U.S. oversight boardFossil fuels are ‘probably dead,’ says Canadian Pacific Railway CEO Hunter Harrison

Canadian Pacific didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.



The damages referred to by ADM in several counts in the lawsuit only amount to “into the millions dollars,” but it is potentially embarrassing for CP because it highlights key areas the railroad has touted in the bid to buy Norfolk Southern Corp.

CP in mid-November disclosed its US$28 billion offer to purchase Norfolk Southern.

The Norfolk, Virginia-based railroad has rebuffed all CP’s approaches so far. CP claimed a deal would result in financial savings in excess of US$1.8 billion annually.

While some rail customers back the bid, many like package delivery companies UPS and FedEx Corp oppose it. Opponents say cost-cutting initiatives would cause service disruptions.

Since septuagenarian railroad legend Hunter Harrison became leader of CP this year, Wall Street has cheered the company’s cost cuts like a success story.

But ADM’s lawsuit claims service disruptions at its facilities in Enderlin and Velva, North Dakota, plus Red Wing, Minnesota are partly caused by CP “participating in imprudent cost-cutting initiatives.”

ADM also blamed the problems on CP’s “engaging in ancillary and diversionary management activities during the period regarding potential rail merger/acquisition partners.”

No. 3 U.S. railroad CSX Corp also rejected a takeover bid from CP at the end of 2014.

The lawsuit also alleges CP did not allow ADM to use alternative rail providers “to mitigate its service deficiencies.” CP has promoted the thought of “open access” that will allow rail customers to use alternatives in similar situations.

? Thomson Reuters 2016