Home » BLOG » Why the budget set an ‘excessively low bar’ with US$25 oil price — and what it means for Ottawa’s spending
oil-federal-budget-2016.jpg

Why the budget set an ‘excessively low bar’ with US$25 oil price — and what it means for Ottawa’s spending

The Liberal government could still meet its budget targets if oil prices fall to US$25 a barrel this season and Canada’s economy only grows by one percent.

That’s thanks to a $6 billion contingency fund Finance Minister Bill Morneau has generated into this year’s $29.4 billion budget deficit, though he has not explained how he intends to use that contingency plan if that bearish scenario fails to materialize.

The government’s base case scenario requires oil prices to stay at US$40 a barrel (based on the Western Texas Intermediate benchmark) but for the Canadian economy to develop at 1.4 percent this season.

If that plays out – and it is the consensus forecast among economists – then your Liberals may have an additional six billion to either help pay off debt or put into additional spending.

“By setting the bar excessively low to begin, the Finance Minister now has lots of space to manoeuvre on the spending front, while still hitting the (inflated) deficit targets published now,” said Robert Kavcic, senior economist at BMO Capital Markets. “In other words, when the economy performs as expected, Ottawa can spend yet another $4 billion, but still claim that they ‘beat their deficit projection’ by $2 billion.”

Caution may be warranted, of course, because crude prices have consistently defied any predictions made by economists. However the US$25 scenario would envision prices – which on Wednesday pushed back above US$40 a barrel – falling to a new post-crisis low and at their weakest level since 2002.

There are also signs that Canada’s economy could surprise towards the upside this season, as recent data shows that exports are gaining strength on the back of the lower Canadian dollar and weak oil prices. All of that raises questions regarding if the contingency – the largest since former Liberal Pm Paul Martin’s $7 billion contingency in 2005 – is essential.

Related

About privatefinancetips

x

Check Also

investors1.jpg

Commodities could be headed for ‘buffalo jump’ as investors rush for the exits, Barclays warns

Commodities including oil and copper are in chance of steep declines as recent advances aren’t ...

ebay.jpg

eBay aims to transform shopping experience to compete with online giants Alibaba, Amazon

TORONTO – EBay, regarded in the early days as an endless repository for Beanie babies ...

kinross.jpg

Kinross study results should be ‘constructive step forward’ for Tasiast

The Tasiast mine in Mauritania has been a giant black cloud over Kinross Gold Corp. ...